Osha Thai Noodle on Geary

I've been to this Osha several times, and each time I leave with the same thought: "Why is this place so freaking popular?"
Here's my theory:
A) They are open late and close to several bars.
B) They don't completely suck.
C) There isn't a C. I just thought the list would sound more complete if I had a third positive thing to say about this place.

I know that almost no one will agree with me on this, but I don't like their food that much. I am huge fan of Thai food, but nothing I've ever eaten there has impressed me.

Today, I had lunch there with my dad and ordered a noodle soup -supposedly their specialty. I got the duck. It was all veiny and weird. I think it may also have been a little old - the meat had that multi-colored sheen on the surface that ham gets when it's been in the fridge too long, and it tasted slightly metallic. The broth was briney. My favorite part was the bean sprouts, and they were slightly overcooked.

Maybe I'm being too harsh on this place. It really isn't that bad, and, I realize most of their business probably comes from drunk people, and I'll admit I've never eaten there under the influence. Perhaps I should try.

Otherwise, the portions are big, and the atmosphere is pretty good, except for the annoying, loud techno music. (Possibly another reason why people like it so much.) The service, however, is worse every time I go.

As for the other Oshas, I haven't been to any of them, so I can't say anything about the chain as a whole.

If you're in that neighborhood during regular hours and looking for good Thai, I would recommend Ar Roi, which is a little pricier but feels worth it, or Chai Yo up on Polk street. It's a bit farther and the seating is cramped, but I've been there many times and was only disappointed once. (That is a story for another day.) The prices are good and the service is always friendly.

Osha Thai Noodle on Geary gets an overall 5 out of 10.
Service: 3
Food: 6.2
Atmosphere: 5